Skip to Content

What to Serve at Your Taylor Swift Super Bowl Party

Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce are a big conversation, and you’ve assembled your A-Team to cheer them both on at the Super Bowl. Here are the dishes (and drinks!) that should be your first string.

Whether you’re more of a 1989 girlie or a fan of a classic like Red, there’s something for everyone here.

(By the way, the San Francisco 49ers and Kansas City Chiefs basically have the exact same team colors, so these red recipes will work on several levels! Honestly, your grumpy boyfriend and his friends won’t even catch the reference if you don’t tell them.)

If you’re burning red, pick a couple of these 22 dishes and drinks to whip up for game day. There’s something for everyone here, and we went a little more experimental with some ideas than others, but I think the Swifties see what we’re going for here!

  1. Big Red Margarita Recipe
    • Red margarita photo
    • This eye-catching Big Red Margarita tastes every bit as good as it looks! It’s first on this list for a reason — imagine your guests walking into a tray of these pre-made. They’ll fall more in love than T & T.
  2. Red Velvet Thumbnail Cookies Recipe
    • Red Velvet Thumbprint Cookies Photo
    • Thumbprint cookies are my favorite cookie. I love how small and soft they are and the filling is always just the perfect little treat in the middle. Red velvet thumbprint cookies are a version I like for all the winter holidays. I love the soft red velvet paired with velvety cream cheese icing whenever I …
  3. Strawberry Tartlets Recipe
    • Strawberry Tartlets Photo
    • Strawberry Tartlets uses the fresh strawberries and bakes them into tartlets everyone will love. Delightful.
  4. Upside Down Tomato Basil Tartlets Recipe
    • Upside Down Tomato Basil Tartlets Photo
    • Upside Down Tomato Basil Tartlets will be the highlight of your Super Bowl party. Serve as an appetizer before kickoff!
  5. Lemon Cranberry Bread Recipe
    • Lemon Cranberry Bread Photo
    • This lemon cranberry bread is quick and easy to make. It’s filled with tart cranberries in a sweet, lemon flavored bread with a lemon glaze.
  6. Roasted Red Pepper Prosciutto Stromboli Recipe
    • Roasted Red Pepper Prosciutto Stromboli Photo
    • When it comes to lunch, the mighty sandwich tends to take the front row spot in my line of options. I love a hearty sub filled with all sorts of deliciousness but one of my favorites is definitely prosciutto, fresh mozzarella and roasted red peppers. There’s just something about that thin, salty prosciutto with the creamy fresh mozzarella …
  7. Red Velvet Cheesecake Brownie Recipe
    • Red Velvet Cheesecake Brownies Picture
    • Red Velvet Cheesecake Brownies make for a perfect Super Bowl dessert, but we recommend you make extra to also have a little Valentine’s Day treat.
  8. Bloody Mary Chicken Wings Recipe
    • Bloody Mary Chicken Wings Photo
    • When January rolls around, so many people are focused on finding recipes to back up their resolutions; this usually means lighter fare. Words like healthy, skinny, and lightened-up take over the search bar. I totally get that. The holidays kick my butt, too. For me though, January triggers something entirely different—a craving for chicken wings! I …
  9. Cherry Lime Rickey with Gin Recipe
    • Cherry Lime Rickey with Gin Photo
    • Cherry Lime Rickey with Gin is tart, sweet, and kicked up with gin. Touchdown!
  10. Pomegranate Old Fashioned Recipe
    • Pomegranate Old Fashioned Photo
    • Pomegranate Old Fashioned can be whipped up easily for your party and will definitely be a hit. Imagine sipping this during Usher’s halftime performance!
  11. Baked Strawberry Pie Recipe
    • Baked Strawberry Pie Photo
    • Pie, at a Super Bowl party? Yes, obviously, why not! People will be impressed, we promise.
  12. Cherry Lime Popsicles Recipe
    • Cherry Lime Popsicles Photo
    • Cherry Lime Popsicles would be a delicious and satisfying way to cool off after sultry looks between Travis and Taylor. Tart, sweet, and refreshing!
  13. Champagne Jello Shots Recipe
    • Champagne Jello Shots Photo
    • Our champagne Jello shots are a delicious way to celebrate! This easy champagne Jello shots recipe is made with watermelon gelatin, but switch it up by using the red flavor.
  14. Paleo Stuffed Peppers Recipe
    • Paleo Stuffed Peppers Photo
    • There are few things more beautiful than an assortment of peppers adding bright colors to a casserole or taking an omelet to the next level. If I had to pick a favorite, I’d definitely go for red peppers every time. Sliced and eaten raw by themselves or used as a vessel to transport dip from a bowl …
  15. Beet Hummus Recipe
    • Beet Hummus Photo
    • Are you a beet lover? If not, I can completely relate. I used to have a shaky relationship with beets, myself. Their ‘earthy’ flavor didn’t really get it done for me. Fortunately, after trying beets several ways, I finally discovered that if I embraced their unique taste, I really loved them. In fact, I can …
  16. Harissa Goat Cheese Deviled Eggs Recipe
    • Harissa Goat Cheese Deviled Eggs Photo
    • I am a firm believer that deviled eggs are a year round food. They are always an appropriate appetizer to bring to family get-togethers, whether it’s Christmas time, Easter, Mother’s Day, or just an amazing summer BBQ. We recently took a huge tray of deviled eggs to a school pot luck and they were gone …
  17. Raspberry Mojito Recipe
    • Raspberry Mojito Photo
    • I don’t know about you, but I am kinda sorta in LUHVEEEE with the fact that it’s FINALLY summer weather. I mean, I am all down with the sun-showing-it’s-face-bbq-all-the-things thang that summer brings about. HOW-EV-ER, you know what makes me really excited for the increase in daily-degrees? PATIO WEATHER. More specifically, cocktails-on-abovementioned-patio-weather. I mean, have you …
  18. Grilled Pizza Recipe
    • Grilled Pizza Photo
    • I always thought pizza was the ultimate kids’ food until I met my husband.  When he was a child, he wouldn’t eat pizza. How strange is that? Yes, it’s weird but I do love him anyway. Once he reached his teenage years, something changed and by college he couldn’t get enough of the stuff.  I …
  19. Bloody Mary Recipe
    • Bloody Mary Photo
    • A Bloody Mary is the perfect Sunday morning cocktail. And the Super Bowl is on a Sunday, so…